Method · Money
Iterate the rubric when the judge disagrees
When the judge disagrees with your labels, read its explanation and decide whether the judge was right or you were right — ask 'Is my rubric wrong or were my human labels wrong?' Tighten rubric criteria (e.g., instead of 'includes forward-looking analysis', write 'includes forward-looking analysis with specific recommendations or guidance'), then rerun the judge on the same examples and see if the disagreement goes away — this is rubric iteration.
AI Engineer · From Vibes to Production: Evaluating and Shipping AI Agents That Work 101 — Laurie Voss, Arize AI
Method described by Laurie Voss
Method preserved for inspection; not a verified protocol.